Before returning to PA, Gabe Cicala served as Director of Lake Norman Sales and Broker at Stone Realty Group, with over 85 closed transactions, totaling nearly $40,000,000 in volume. In 2025 alone he closed 29 transactions for $15.2M, and through 2026 has already recorded 31 transactions and $11M+ in volume. Stone Realty Group also recognized him as Strongest Negotiator, Top 3 Producer, and Stone Standard Excellence Award recipient. FastExpert names him a Top Agent, Zillow lists him as a Top Agent with a perfect five-star rating across 40+ 5 star reviews and, Gabe has consistently ranked in the top 3% of agents in his market. 

​

The negotiation record behind those titles is documented and specific. When a seller needed an offer improved, he moved the number from $1M to $1.13M. When a buyer needed protection, he secured a home 25% below list price and 18% below appraised value over a 3 month long negotiation. Both outcomes were deliberate, not fortunate.​

Before real estate, Gabe served as Director of Marketing inside a boutique brokerage in Orlando, Florida under a mentor ranked in the top 0.001% of agents nationally, who Gabe describes as "the most effective agent he has ever seen." Gabe also grew up with a construction background, managing projects across Pennsylvania including the closeout of a $25M elementary school and the renovation of a public transportation center for Fidevia in Lititz. He graduated summa cum laude from High Point University with a Bachelors in Business Administration, a concentration in Entrepreneurship, and a minor in Marketing. Those disciplines converge in the structure he brings to every transaction he runs.​​

His core markets cover the full Lancaster County and surrounding areas: Lititz, Ephrata, East Petersburg, Lancaster, Mountville, Millersville, Mount Joy, Manheim, New Holland, Leola, and more, extending into broader Columbia, Harrisburg, or Reading  for move-up buyers and sellers, luxury listings, first-time home buyers, out-of-state buyer representation, and investors who need deep knowledge of the tax advantages of real estate investments. Gabe is trusted because he understands both the data and the psychology of every offer on both sides of the table.​ 

Gabe understands the emotions of buying and selling, owning investment properties himself and purchasing his first home at just 24 years old. He aims to take as much stress off your shoulders throughout the process. To do this, Gabe has a vendor for every possible need, whether that is an inspector, contractor, plumber, electrician, handyman, roofer, and more. Working with Gabe instantly opens you up to a world of possibilities with his extensive list of connections and he is excited to work with you!