top of page
Search

First-Time Home Buyer Guide to Lancaster County, PA: Everything You Need to Know in 2026

Oct 9
13 min read

Updated: Oct 23

Downtown Lancaster, PA skyline at sunset

Buying your first home can feel a lot more complicated than it actually is. How much money do you need? Do you really need 20% down? Should you wait for interest rates to drop? How long does buying a house take? What happens after you make an offer? And in a competitive area like Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, how do you make sure you're actually getting a good home and not just rushing into one?

I'm Gabe Cicala, a Lancaster County real estate agent and Lititz native, and I've helped dozens of first-time homebuyers through this exact process. One of the biggest things I've learned is that most first-time buyers aren't incapable of buying a home. They simply haven't had somebody clearly explain their options to them, so this guide is designed to do exactly that.

If you'd rather have me walk you through the entire process personally, I host a free First-Time Homebuyer Masterclass every Wednesday at 6:30 p.m. where I break all of this down in more detail and answer questions live. Sign up for my free Lancaster County First-Time Homebuyer Masterclass here.


Can I Buy a Home in Lancaster County Without 20% Down?

Yes. You do not necessarily need 20% down to buy a house in Lancaster County, and this is probably the biggest misconception I hear from first-time homebuyers. Twenty percent down can have benefits, but it is not a requirement for every buyer.

The loan types I most commonly see first-time buyers use are conventional, FHA, USDA and VA loans. Depending on your approval and your circumstances, those options can allow a buyer to purchase with far less than 20% down, and in some cases with as little as 0% down. That alone breaks the stereotype that you need to save up 20% before you can buy a home.

None of this means everyone qualifies for every option, and a lender is the right person to walk you through the specifics of what fits your situation. But if the only reason you haven't explored buying a home is because you believe you need tens of thousands of dollars for a 20% down payment, talk to a knowledgeable lender before assuming homeownership is out of reach. You may be much closer than you think.


How Much Money Do I Actually Need to Buy My First Home?

There isn't one answer that applies to every first-time homebuyer. Your cash needed to close can include your down payment, closing costs, inspections and other transaction-related expenses, and the exact number depends heavily on the loan you choose and the deal that your Realtor negotiates. This is also why I don't recommend deciding whether you can afford a house by doing random calculations online. Start with the numbers that actually apply to you.

A good lender can determine what financing you qualify for, and then your Realtor can help you understand how those numbers translate into actual homes in Lancaster County. There are also situations where I can negotiate for a seller to contribute toward a buyer's closing costs. It doesn't happen on every property and depends heavily on the strength of the market and the individual negotiation, but seller concessions can make an enormous difference for a first-time buyer who would rather keep additional cash in the bank after closing.


Is Lancaster County, PA Competitive for First-Time Homebuyers?

Yes, certain parts of Lancaster County can be very competitive, but that doesn't mean first-time buyers can't win here. One of the unique things about the Lancaster County real estate market is that demand can remain strong even when buyers are hearing nationally that the housing market has slowed. A great house in a great location can still sell quickly, so you shouldn't assume you can move slowly when the right one comes along.

Lancaster County has established communities, desirable towns, employment centers, farmland, restaurants, markets, parks and highly sought-after school districts. Areas such as Lititz, Manheim Township and other communities around the county continue to receive significant attention from buyers, and Lititz and Lancaster County are regularly recognized among the best small towns and best places to live in the country.

The downside for a first-time buyer is competition. The upside is that you're purchasing in an established area where people continue to want to live. That's why I wouldn't tell a first-time homebuyer simply to find the cheapest house possible. Price matters, but so do location, condition, future buyer demand and your eventual resale.


How Long Does It Take to Buy Your First House?

Potentially much faster than you think. Another major misconception I hear from first-time buyers is that buying a house automatically takes several months. It certainly can take months if you're casually searching for the right property, but once you're prepared financially and find the right home, the actual transaction can move extremely quickly.

I've had a first-time buyer call me around 3:00 on a Friday afternoon because she and her fiancé were beginning to think about purchasing a home before getting married. She had found one house she wanted to see. While looking at the options, I found another nearby property that I thought fit them even better, so I scheduled both, and they fell in love with the home I had found. I connected them with my lender immediately. We got their financing moving, obtained their preapproval, wrote the offer and got them under contract that same day. They closed roughly three and a half weeks later.

They went from essentially saying, "Maybe we should start thinking about buying a house," to owning one in less than a month. That isn't a guarantee that every transaction will happen that quickly, but it shows what is possible when you have the right Realtor, lender and team around you.


What Should I Do Before Looking at Houses in Lancaster County?

Before looking at dozens of homes online, there are a few questions I want my buyers to answer. Why do you want to move? When would you ideally like to move? What needs to be different about your next living situation for moving to actually be worth it? Then we figure out the financial side. If you're financing the purchase, I get you connected with a strong lender so we understand exactly what you're comfortable spending and what you may qualify for. Only then do we start narrowing down homes.

A common first-time-buyer mistake is trying to figure everything out alone before contacting a Realtor because you think you're supposed to already know what you're doing. You're not. That's my job. You shouldn't need to become an expert in mortgages, contracts, inspections, appraisals, negotiations and Pennsylvania real estate before you're allowed to buy your first house.


What Does the First-Time Home Buying Process Look Like?

While every transaction is a little different, the process generally looks something like this:

1. Buyer consultation. We talk about why you're considering buying, your timeline, your priorities and what you want your life to look like after you move.

2. Financing and preapproval. If you're financing the purchase, I'll help connect you with a lender who can review your financial situation and explain your options.

3. Build the home search. We identify the areas, property types and features that make sense for you.

4. Tour homes. This is where we learn a lot. I don't just listen to what a buyer tells me they like before we start. I watch their reactions when we're actually inside houses. Sometimes buyers discover that something they thought was essential doesn't matter nearly as much as they expected, while something they barely considered becomes a must-have, so we continuously fine-tune the search.

5. Analyze the property. Before writing an offer, we need to understand more than the asking price. What have comparable homes sold for? How long has this one been available? Does it appear to have deferred maintenance? How much competition are we dealing with? What terms might matter to the seller? A good deal isn't always simply the house with the lowest price.

6. Write and negotiate the offer. Price matters, but there are multiple pieces of a Pennsylvania real estate contract that can affect the strength of your offer and your protection as a buyer.

7. Inspections and due diligence. If your agreement includes inspections, this gives you an opportunity to better understand the condition of the property and determine how to proceed based on what is discovered.

8. Financing and appraisal. Your lender works through final underwriting and any required appraisal while we continue managing the transaction.

9. Final walkthrough and settlement. We verify the property before settlement, sign the final documents and you get the keys.

My goal is that you don't spend this entire process wondering, "What am I supposed to do next?" I tell you.


What Can a Good Buyer's Agent Actually Do for a First-Time Buyer?

One of my favorite first-time buyer transactions involved clients who had absolutely no idea where to start. They didn't have connections in real estate, they didn't know which homes they should be looking at and they didn't know the process. That's completely fine. We started by figuring out what they actually wanted, and then I began showing them properties. As we toured homes, I paid attention to their reactions and continuously adjusted the search until we found the home they're living in today.

And then the inspection found problems. Instead of treating that as a disaster, we negotiated. Not only did they purchase one of the better price-per-square-foot opportunities in that neighborhood, but I was also able to negotiate an additional 4% in seller concessions and repairs to help them move in with greater peace of mind.

I've had first-time homebuyers describe me in reviews as a "godsend" and a "guardian angel" during the process, and that's exactly how I think a first-time buyer should feel about their agent. You shouldn't feel like you're bothering your Realtor because you don't understand something. You should feel like you have somebody standing between you and potentially very expensive mistakes.


I'm Paying $2,000+ Per Month in Rent. Should I Buy a House Instead?

Not necessarily, but you should probably at least find out what your options are. Renting and buying both have legitimate advantages, and buying a home isn't automatically the right financial decision for every person. But here's the difference I want renters to understand. When you pay your landlord $2,000 in rent, you are paying for your housing for that month. You don't acquire ownership in the property because of that payment.

With a mortgage, part of your monthly payment goes toward paying down the amount you borrowed. Your payment generally stays the same, but the makeup of it changes over time. Earlier on, more of it goes toward interest. As time goes on, the interest portion generally decreases and the amount going toward principal increases. That principal reduction creates equity. So if two people each have a $2,000 housing payment, but one is renting and the other owns, those two payments can have very different long-term financial consequences.

Homeowners can also potentially benefit from appreciation if their property increases in value, although appreciation is never guaranteed. Homeowners also take on expenses renters may not have, including maintenance, repairs, property taxes, insurance and transaction costs. That's why I don't believe in simply shouting "renting is throwing money away." The better question is this: if you're already paying $2,000 or more every month for housing, have you at least compared that with what owning could look like for you? If you haven't, that's where I would start.

Country road with a farm silo at sunset in Lancaster County, PA

What Should I Know About Living in Lancaster County Before Buying?

This is where local knowledge matters. Lancaster County isn't one uniform market. Lancaster City, Lititz, Manheim Township, Ephrata, Mount Joy, Elizabethtown, Strasburg, East Petersburg, Millersville, Columbia, Denver, Leola, New Holland and the surrounding rural areas can offer very different lifestyles.

One piece of advice I give people is simple: drive your commute at the actual time you would normally be driving it. Don't look at Google Maps at 11:00 a.m. on Saturday and assume that's what your Tuesday commute at 5:00 p.m. will feel like. Lancaster County doesn't have massive six-lane highways connecting every community, and traffic on some of our main roads can change considerably depending on time of day. And this is Lancaster County, so we also share many of our roads with horse-and-buggy traffic.

That's part of what makes this area unique. Our significant agricultural community is also why Lancaster County has access to something I think is genuinely special: local farms, produce stands, farmers markets, fresh eggs, dairy products and food produced right here in the county. If you're moving here from another part of the country, those details matter. You're not simply buying four walls. You're choosing the community that surrounds those four walls.


Should I Wait Until Mortgage Rates Come Down?

Nobody can promise you exactly what mortgage rates or home prices will do next, so I don't think "I'll buy when rates drop" is a complete strategy. The question I would rather ask is whether buying the right house today at today's payment would make sense for your finances and your life. If the answer is no, don't buy it. If the answer is yes, then we can evaluate the opportunity in front of us.

Remember that lower interest rates can also bring additional buyers back into the market. More buying power sounds fantastic until you're competing with significantly more people for the same house. That's why waiting for the "perfect market" can be frustrating. I'm much more interested in helping you identify a good opportunity for your circumstances than trying to predict the exact bottom of mortgage rates or home prices.


How Do I Know if a House Is a Good Deal?

This is another area where first-time buyers can get caught up in the wrong number. A price reduction does not automatically make a home a good deal, and paying full asking price does not automatically make it a bad one. When I'm evaluating a property with a buyer, I'm looking at things like comparable recent sales, price per square foot, property condition, days on market, competition, seller motivation, inspection findings, potential concessions, location, school district, lot, functional layout, future buyer demand and resale considerations.

Sometimes the better opportunity is a cosmetically ugly home in a fantastic location. Sometimes it's a property that's been sitting because it was originally overpriced. Sometimes the opportunity is not getting $20,000 off the asking price. It's negotiating thousands of dollars toward closing costs or getting significant repairs handled. There is more than one way to get a good deal in real estate.


Do School Districts Matter When Buying a Home in Lancaster County?

They can matter even if you don't currently have children. Lancaster County has multiple highly sought-after areas and school districts, and demand for certain locations can have an impact on both competition when you're purchasing and potential buyer demand when you eventually sell.

You should never buy a property solely because somebody tells you that prices will definitely increase. There are no guarantees in real estate. But I do want first-time buyers thinking about their exit strategy before they ever make an offer. Someday you're probably going to sell this house. Who is likely to want it from you? That's a question worth asking before you buy.


What Is the Biggest Mistake Lancaster County First-Time Homebuyers Make?

Waiting too long to get educated. You don't have to be ready to buy tomorrow to talk to a Realtor or lender. In fact, I'd rather meet you six or twelve months before you're ready than six hours before you want to submit an offer. The earlier we talk, the more time we have to improve your position.

Maybe you need to work on your credit. Maybe you're already qualified and don't realize it. Maybe you need to save a little more. Maybe a different loan option changes your entire plan. Maybe buying isn't the right decision yet. All of those are useful answers. What doesn't help is spending another year assuming you're not ready without actually finding out.


First-Time Homebuyer FAQ: Lancaster County, PA

Do first-time homebuyers need 20% down in Pennsylvania?

No. Many buyers purchase with far less than 20% down. Conventional, FHA, USDA and VA loans are common options for first-time buyers, and depending on approval and circumstances, some buyers are able to put as little as 0% down. A lender can tell you which options fit your situation.

Is Lancaster County a good place to buy a first home?

Lancaster County continues to experience strong housing demand and contains a wide range of communities, from Lancaster City to established suburbs, small towns and rural areas. The right location depends on your budget, commute, lifestyle and long-term plans.

How quickly can I close on a house?

There is no universal timeline, but properly prepared financed buyers can sometimes close within several weeks. I've personally helped a first-time buyer go from initially calling me to getting under contract the same day and closing approximately three and a half weeks later.

Should I get preapproved before touring homes?

Usually, yes. Understanding your financing before seriously shopping helps establish an appropriate price range and puts you in a much better position if you find a property you want to pursue quickly.

Can I get seller closing-cost assistance as a first-time buyer?

Potentially. Seller concessions depend on the individual property, market conditions, your financing, the appraisal and the negotiation. I've negotiated concessions for first-time buyers before, including one transaction where my buyers received concessions and repairs totaling approximately 4%.

Can I buy a home in Lancaster County with zero down?

Some buyers are able to, depending on their approval and circumstances. The best way to find out is to talk with a lender who can review your situation and explain what you may qualify for.

What towns should first-time homebuyers consider in Lancaster County?

There isn't one town that's best for every first-time buyer. Depending on your budget and lifestyle, your search could include Lancaster, Lititz, Manheim Township, East Petersburg, Mount Joy, Ephrata, Elizabethtown, Columbia, Millersville, Strasburg, Denver, New Holland, Leola and other communities throughout Lancaster County. The best approach is to first determine your budget, commute and priorities and then compare the areas that actually fit those criteria. For a detailed breakdown of prices, school districts and local favorites in each area, see my guide to the different towns in Lancaster County.


Want to Buy Your First Home in Lancaster County? Start Here.

If you've made it this far, you probably have more questions. Good. You should. Buying a home is a major decision, and I would rather you understand exactly what you're doing than rush into something because somebody told you that you "need to buy now."

That's why I host a FREE First-Time Homebuyer Masterclass every Wednesday at 6:30 p.m. I walk through the buying process from the first conversation all the way through getting your keys, including financing, down payments, buyer agency, searching for homes, contracts, negotiating, inspections, appraisals, closing and the mistakes I see first-time buyers make. You don't need to already be preapproved. You don't need to know whether you're buying next month or next year. And you definitely don't need to already understand real estate.

Sign up for the next free Lancaster County First-Time Homebuyer Masterclass and I'll show you exactly how the process works. If you'd rather talk privately, you can also reach out to me directly or book a call and ask me for a custom list of Lancaster County homes that fit what you're looking for.


About Gabe Cicala

Hey, I'm Gabe! I'm a Lititz native with about 85 career transactions and nearly $40M in closed volume and I'd love to work with you. If you're thinking about buying or selling in Lancaster County, give me a call and let's make it happen.

Gabe Cicala

Lusk & Associates | Sotheby's International Realty

717-744-0317

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page